In part 1 we covered NEM 3, its effects and history.

While I was writing this series the SF Chronicle published this very approachable article by Chase DiFeliciantonio, These homeowners’ PG&E bills reveal California’s dramatic shift on solar.

One of the story lines he provides is Adrian Macneil from San Anselmo, a CEO of a software startup. “My PG&E bills were going crazy during the pandemic,” Macneil said, sometimes touching $700 per month. He figures that even with the cost of a battery, the system will pay for itself in the next six to seven years — maybe faster given how quickly electric rates are going up. “It’s much better to control your own destiny,” he said.”

“Novato’s SolarCraft, for instance, said it is now installing batteries along with panels on just about every job, including on the side of Macneil’s San Anselmo home. That increases project costs by 30% to 40% for homeowners, said CEO Phil Alwitt, which he conceded can make solar less attractive to install and lengthen the time it takes to pay off.”

Solar Panels

Solar Panels

This is exactly what we are going to look at in part 2. My home 2025 project is installing Solar and Battery Storage in my new house - so I’ll share how the numbers work for me.  (Well it’s not a new house otherwise it would already have solar as all new houses in California are required to have solar since 2020.  It’s new to my wife and me.). I feel strongly that solar plus storage is the only way to go.

I followed a process that starts with the simple ROI calculation:

(Total System Cost – Value of Incentives) ÷ Cost of Electricity ÷ Annual Electricity Usage = Payback Period

Part of the Total System Cost would be financing if needed.  Rates currently run from 5.5% to 8% depending on your credit rating.  I am going to use 6.25% for me as that’s what the quotes I received via EnergySage offered.

Value of incentives.  For now, everyone qualifies for the Federal Income Tax Credit (ITC).  The ITC allows 30% of the installation costs to be applied to your taxes and can be rolled over year-to-year. (IRS Form 5695).

Included in the Cost of Electricity we’re going to add in a Utility Rate Inflation factor to account for rate increases during the payoff period.  Most ROI calculators don’t include this but Mr. Macneil mentions it and he’s right.  Besides lowering my bill, electrifying our house, preparing for an EV, a big selling point for me shielding ourselves from the substantial rise in rate increases that we’ve seen in recent years.

Take a look: The alarming Utility Rate Inflation trends…

According to High Country News: Across the West, electricity rates rose an average of 17% between 2018 and 2023, amid record-breaking wildfires, storms and extreme heat.  Late last year, thousands of ratepayers wrote to the Wyoming Mountain public service commission, protesting a nearly 30% rate hike proposed by Rocky Power.

Oregon Capital Chronicle reports that customers of Oregon’s largest investor-owned electric utility pay more than 40% more for their electricity today than they did just four years ago.  Portland General Electric, raised rates, on average, by 11% in 2022, 7% in 2023, and 18% in 2024.  In February of this year PGE asked the Oregon Public Utilities Commission for a 7.4% rate hike that would go into effect next year. Then in August the utility upped the ante by requesting approval to instead raise its rates by 10.9% for 2025.  Thus drawing the ire of Oregon’s US Senator Ron Wyden who demanded an explanation.  “After 41%, it’s time to take a timeout and give a break to the ratepayer.”

Bill Gurgol of Solar Billreview pulls no punches as he tracks California’s PG&E’s rate hikes. 10 years ago he learned that Pacific Gas and Electric had an average increase of “6.8% per year over decades”, within the last 10 years average rate increases have been closer to 10% yearly (confirmed by the Public Advocates Office).  He declares “there is NO middle ground, batteries are the future!”.

Rate increases of California’s Investor Owned Utilities

Rate increases of California’s Investor Owned Utilities

All quite alarming.

From the Energy Toolbase White Paper - Electric Bill Inflation in California  I learned of the worrisome recent trend of accelerated California rates of 13.6%, 16.9% and 15.4% from 2020 to 2023.  However going back further they meticulously tracked California utility prices from 2014-2023 and came up with an inflation rate of 5.3% across all 3 California investor owned utilities.

There’s a growing concern that home owners will end up paying for the increased infrastructure that Data Centers are starting to demand.  “A lot of governors and local political leaders who wanted economic growth and vitality from these data centers are now realizing it can come at a cost of increased consumer bills,” Neil Chatterjee, former chair of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission told the Washington Post.  We’ll dedicate another article to Data Center demand soon.